College football just exploded—again.** But this time, it’s not a buzzer-beater or a Heisman-worthy performance lighting the fuse. It’s a single *statement*—a declaration from ESPN that has split the sport right down the middle.
> “Ohio State is the greatest college football program of all time.”
That sentence—broadcast on a nationally televised ESPN panel—has unleashed a tsunami of rage, debate, and fiery condemnation from across the NCAA football map.
**And now, everyone’s asking the same question:**
If not Buckeye… **then WHO?**
ESPN’s “Powerhouse of All Time” List Breaks the Internet
The segment aired during ESPN’s annual *College Football Royalty Countdown*, where analysts ranked the top 10 programs in NCAA history. When the panel placed **Ohio State at #1**, ahead of Alabama, Georgia, Notre Dame, Texas, and others—**all hell broke loose.**
Twitter/X went nuclear. Fans screamed bias. Coaches subtly threw shade. Former players clapped back. And college football forums went into full meltdown mode.
> “This is nothing short of SEC slander,” one Alabama fan wrote.
> “Pure delusion,” added a Georgia die-hard.
> “Notre Dame BUILT college football,” claimed an Irish loyalist.
And it didn’t stop there. Several elite programs made **official statements** or gave veiled reactions during pressers—**proving this wasn’t just internet noise.**
Why ESPN Chose Ohio State
According to ESPN insiders, the decision was based on a formula that included:
All-time win percentage
Bowl game appearances and wins
National titles
Decade-by-decade consistency
NFL draft success
* Cultural and fanbase influence
By that logic, **Ohio State checks all the boxes**. The Buckeyes boast:
* 8 national titles
* Over 950 all-time wins
A winning percentage of .732
86 consensus All-Americans A record number of NFL draft picks
A top-5 finish in more than half of the past 20 seasons
ESPN’s lead analyst boldly stated:
> “They’ve been elite for almost 100 years. They don’t rebuild—they reload. No other team has remained this dominant, this consistently.”
Alabama STRIKES BACK: “Don’t Forget the Dynasty”
**Tuscaloosa was the first to clap back.** Alabama fans and officials alike blasted ESPN for what they called “revisionist history.”
> “We have 18 national titles. Our program defined modern dominance,” a Crimson Tide representative said.
Indeed, Alabama under Nick Saban became a **dynasty of dynasties**, with 6 national championships from 2009 to 2020. Many argue that peak Bama beats *any* version of Ohio State.
Alabama fans took over social media with the hashtag:
BamaBuiltTheGame
Georgia Fumes: “Two-Time Champs and Still No Respect?”
Back-to-back national champions Georgia didn’t stay silent either. The Dawgs’ community accused ESPN of **ignoring recent dominance** in favor of long-term nostalgia.
> “If Georgia wins another title this decade, they will have the most dominant 10-year stretch in modern college football,” said a former SEC coach.
The Bulldogs felt particularly slighted, with fans pointing to **Kirby Smart’s machine-like recruiting**, defensive excellence, and postseason success.
> “Ohio State couldn’t beat Michigan two years in a row. We beat the entire nation.”
Touché?
Notre Dame: “We BUILT the Game You Now Rank Us In”
The most historic program in the NCAA—**Notre Dame**—expressed disgust over being placed outside ESPN’s top 3.
> “Without Notre Dame, college football wouldn’t even *exist* on the national stage,” said a university spokesperson.
With 11 claimed national titles and the legendary legacy of names like Knute Rockne, Joe Montana, and Lou Holtz, the Irish claim they should always be in the GOAT conversation.
They also noted that **Notre Dame played a national schedule before anyone else dared to**, carrying the sport coast to coast.
Texas: “Bias at Its Finest”
Texas fans were furious**, claiming ESPN’s Buckeye lovefest was a symptom of long-running “media market bias.”
> “Of course the Big Ten darlings get the crown. They’re always on TV, even when they’re not winning,” tweeted one Longhorn fan.
The Longhorns, with 4 national titles, a Heisman legacy, and one of the largest athletic departments in the world, called the ranking “a slap in the face.”
And many haven’t forgotten Vince Young’s 2006 Rose Bowl—**still considered one of the greatest performances of all time.**
The Buckeye Nation Responds: “We’ve Earned This”
On the other side of the firestorm, **Ohio State fans reveled in the chaos**. From Columbus to every Buckeye bar in America, it was celebration time.
> “We didn’t ask for this crown, but we’re not taking it off,” one fan wrote.
Buckeye Nation has long felt underappreciated despite their winning legacy, and this declaration from ESPN was the validation they’ve waited decades for.
> “We’ve done it across eras. You want Woody Hayes? Archie Griffin? Urban Meyer? Ryan Day? We’ve BEEN elite.”
So… IF NOT BUCKEYE—THEN WHO?
The question still stands.
Is Alabama’s dynasty more impressive than Ohio State’s consistency?**
* **Should Georgia’s recent domination carry more weight?**
* **Does Notre Dame’s origin-story legacy still matter in the modern era?**
* **Can Texas return to the top and reclaim its throne?**
One thing’s for sure: **This debate isn’t going anywhere.**
College football’s fiercest rivalries now have a new battleground—and it’s no longer on the field.
It’s in the media, the message boards, and every fan’s heart.
So you tell us:
IF NOT BUCKEYE… THEN WHO?
Leave a Reply