Paul Finebaum, the ever-controversial voice of college football, has once again ignited a fiery debate among fans and analysts alike. This time, his target is none other than Georgia Bulldogs head coach Kirby Smart. Known for his polarizing commentary, Finebaum’s latest take on Smart’s place in the coaching pantheon is raising eyebrows across the nation—and it might just be the most shocking statement of his career.
A Stunning Season’s End
The Georgia Bulldogs entered the 2024 season as favorites to contend for another national championship. With back-to-back titles in 2021 and 2022 and a roster teeming with talent, expectations were sky-high. But when the pressure was on, Georgia stumbled. A lackluster performance in the SEC Championship and an early exit in the College Football Playoff left fans questioning what went wrong.
For Finebaum, this disappointing finish provided the perfect backdrop for his scathing assessment of Smart’s legacy.
Finebaum’s Bold Claim
Speaking on his popular radio show, Finebaum didn’t hold back. When asked about Kirby Smart’s place among the greats, he delivered a statement that immediately set social media ablaze:
“Kirby Smart is a great recruiter, no doubt about it,” Finebaum said. “But when it comes to pure coaching ability—game management, in-game adjustments, and handling high-pressure moments—he’s not in the same league as Nick Saban or even Dabo Swinney. In fact, I’d argue he’s still a step below coaches like Brian Kelly or Jim Harbaugh when it comes to the overall craft of coaching.”
The comment was a bombshell, particularly considering Smart’s recent success. To suggest that Georgia’s head coach—who has turned the Bulldogs into a juggernaut—is anything less than elite was enough to send Bulldog Nation into an uproar.
Fans React: Outrage and Agreement
As expected, Finebaum’s remarks divided fans. Georgia supporters took to social media to defend their coach, pointing to his 81% career win percentage, multiple SEC titles, and two national championships as evidence of his dominance.
“How can anyone question Kirby Smart?” one fan tweeted. “He’s built a dynasty at Georgia. Finebaum is just stirring the pot as usual.”
But not everyone disagreed. Critics of Smart’s in-game decisions—particularly in Georgia’s recent losses—were quick to point out moments where the coach’s choices seemed questionable.
“Recruiting talent is one thing,” wrote another commenter. “But coaching is about maximizing that talent when it matters most. Kirby’s teams have fallen short in the biggest games this season. Maybe Finebaum has a point.”
Breaking Down the Argument
To understand Finebaum’s critique, it’s essential to examine both sides of the argument. Kirby Smart’s supporters have a strong case. Since taking over as Georgia’s head coach in 2016, Smart has:
- Amassed a 94–19 record.
- Won two national championships (2021, 2022).
- Claimed five SEC East titles and two SEC Championships.
- Consistently recruited top-three recruiting classes.
These accomplishments are the envy of nearly every program in the country. Yet, Finebaum’s critique focuses on a different aspect of coaching: the ability to adapt and excel under pressure. Critics argue that Smart’s success has often been the result of overwhelming talent rather than tactical brilliance.
In Georgia’s recent losses, some point to:
- Conservative Playcalling: In crucial moments, Smart’s offensive strategy has been accused of lacking creativity.
- Clock Management Issues: Poor time management in high-stakes games has raised questions about his situational awareness.
- Adjustments Against Elite Teams: When faced with teams that match Georgia’s talent, Smart’s ability to adjust mid-game has sometimes come under fire.
How Does Kirby Compare?
To put Smart’s legacy in context, it’s worth comparing him to the coaches Finebaum mentioned. Nick Saban, widely regarded as the greatest college football coach of all time, has seven national titles and an unmatched record in championship games. Dabo Swinney has also proven his mettle with two national titles and a reputation for thriving in high-pressure situations.
Brian Kelly, though lacking a national title, has consistently elevated programs like Notre Dame and LSU to elite status. Jim Harbaugh has turned Michigan into a Big Ten powerhouse, recently breaking through with back-to-back wins over Ohio State and playoff appearances.
Finebaum’s point seems to be that while Smart’s accomplishments are undeniable, his overall coaching ability has yet to reach the same tier as the sport’s most revered figures.
What’s Next for Kirby Smart?
The good news for Georgia fans is that Kirby Smart isn’t going anywhere. His recruiting prowess ensures the Bulldogs will remain contenders for years to come. However, the 2024 season’s disappointing finish has set the stage for a pivotal 2025 campaign.
Smart now faces a challenge: to prove that his success isn’t solely the result of superior talent but also his ability to out-coach his peers when it matters most. This includes refining in-game strategies, adapting to adversity, and showing that Georgia can win not just with talent but with superior tactics and preparation.
Final Thoughts
Paul Finebaum’s critique of Kirby Smart is as bold as it is divisive. By labeling Smart as a step below the greats, Finebaum has reignited the debate over what truly defines coaching greatness. Is it enough to recruit elite talent and win games, or must a coach consistently prove their tactical brilliance under pressure?
For now, Kirby Smart’s legacy remains secure as one of college football’s most successful coaches of the modern era. But as the spotlight intensifies and expectations continue to rise, his ability to adapt and thrive will be under constant scrutiny.
One thing is certain: the 2025 season will be a defining chapter in Smart’s career. Will he silence critics like Finebaum and cement his place among the all-time greats, or will his legacy remain a point of contention? College football fans will be watching—and debating—every step of the way.
Leave a Reply